We’ve got candy on the brain this week, so here are some of our favorite coffee and candy pairings to use with your own Halloween stash. Because we know you have a stash, too.

Novo El Mirador + Reese’s PB Cup

We usually go to Brazil for coffees with that delicious combo of peanut butter and chocolate, but this Guatemalan gem has plenty of that flavor, with a bit of fruity acidity for balance.

Wonderstate Heartstrings + Raisinets

This blend of Ethiopian coffees marries dried fruit, like raisins, but also some fun berries, with a bit of cocoa flavor in the background.

Feast Wush Wush Natural + Starburst

Whatever your favorite fruit flavor is, there’s a decent chance you’ll taste a bit of it in this super fruity Ethiopia.

Maquina Forestal + Terry’s Orange Chocolate

This balanced Colombia makes us think of this orange-scented chocolate treat–not your average Halloween candy, but great fun.